Blog

I Am Procrastinating

What I do when I'm not doing what I'm supposed to be doing.

2009-12-01

Stop It: Blaming The Victim

My love for the Twilight Saga is strong, but that doesn't mean I'm blind to it's faults.

Is a 109 year old vamp digging on a teen chick sweet?
Is baby love, imprint or no, okay in my book?
Is obsessing over a dude 24x7 and ditching your friends acceptable?

No. No. No.

Is the relationship between Edward and Bella abusive? Debate it all you want. But don't debate this:

Is Team Edward Enabling Domestic Violence?

I'm a certified domestic violence counselor. I have been in direct contact with a myriad of victims of domestic abuse and their family members. I will literally shit a brick for you if one of them says, "But it worked out for Bella."

While the article itself makes no claims either way, the title's implication is this:

If you read Twilight, you may think the relationship between Edward and Bella is acceptable and you may stay in an abusive relationship. Therefore YOU, the VICTIM have enabled domestic violence.

You know what enables domestic violence? Dumb shit frakked up thinking that would rather put the onus for violence on the victim, on the media, on a kid's book or hell even on poverty, life circumstances, and troubled childhoods instead exactly where it belongs - in the hands of the abuser.

This is the same kind of thinking that was more obsessed with whether Rihanna would set an example for victims than whether Chris Brown would set an example for abusers.

Yes, I wish all abuse victims could stand up for themselves, but when they can't, don't be the one that slaps them down. They already have someone in their lives who fills that role.

Labels:

7 Comments:

OpenID annemariewrites said...

Tell 'em! This is a great post! Likening domestic violence to Edward Cullen is crazy, for all of your reasons and more.

December 1, 2009 2:07 PM  
Blogger Mary Witzl said...

You're right. I loathe Twilight and can't see that it's a great model for girls, but I can't believe that some kid is going to read it and, accordingly, decide it's okay to abuse or be abused. Domestic violence is far too complex an issue to deal with so simply.

December 1, 2009 2:30 PM  
Blogger Ello said...

Excellent post Martha! I have to tell you I had a very similar conversation with Oldest after watching Twilight and New Moon with her. Um except without the cursing. I really want to see more female empowerment stories with romances. What's wrong with that?

December 1, 2009 7:32 PM  
Anonymous Martha Flynn said...

I want to see my story in print, too, Ello! Muhahahahaha! :)

Thanks, guys. I don't really like being all political on my blog, but this issue is very personal for me (in fact...it's featuring into my current work in progress!)

December 1, 2009 7:39 PM  
Blogger Tetonia said...

you said it Ello. I ask myself everytime I browse the YA section at the book store. Where are the stories of women who can stand on their own, save themselves from danger, while having the romance too. I've looked for this story for years and when i couldn't find one. I wrote it.

Awesome post Martha. I think it's easy for young girls to get swept away in the fantasy of Bella and Edward and ignore the signs that their relationship is no good for them.

December 1, 2009 8:28 PM  
Blogger JD said...

amen, sista!

December 2, 2009 6:36 PM  
OpenID mom911 said...

Bravo! Great post.

We need to quite looking so deep into things that don't exist because we are missing the big issues right in front of our faces. To all of those people ranting and raving about the insensitivity of SNL (or Twilight or whatever), why arent you helping out in womens shelters or just opening up your arms to real women in need right in your neighborhood?

The entertainment industry is just that: entertainment. Focus on cold hard facts and you won't need a magnifying glass to figure out who's to blame.

Dude! I love you more each day Martha! :-)

December 8, 2009 3:13 AM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home